India recently overtook Japan to become the world’s fourth-largest economy. This major achievement brings joy across India and signals its growing global influence. Many Indians see this as the result of strong economic growth, increasing industry, and the country’s large, young workforce. As India now looks forward to surpassing Germany and reaching the third position, attention turns to how major global powers like the United States respond to this rise. This milestone stirred debate in the US media about whether India is poised to become the “new China” in America’s economic and strategic calculus.
Mixed Views From US
While US officials continue to support the idea of strong US-India ties, some American media platforms express concern. Conservative news outlets, in particular, see India’s growth as possibly hurting American workers. A recent report by WND.com warns that American investments in India could be harming the US economy. The report’s title, “U.S. pension funds used to fuel India’s rise – and America’s fall,” shows how serious some see this issue.
US Investments Concerns
The WND report claims that many American states, including California, New York, and Texas, have invested over $50 billion in India through pension and development funds. These investments, according to the article, help India grow but result in fewer jobs and less money for American workers. The article also criticizes American officials for encouraging such investments, saying they put foreign interests above their own people.
The US media article highlights a statement by Indian External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar, saying, “The weaker player solicits or manipulates stronger forces to its advantage.” The report interprets this as India using global powers for its own benefit without being loyal to any single partner. It suggests that India is using the US as a tool to grow its economy, not as a true ally.
Comparison With China
The article draws comparisons between America’s past investments in China and its current push to support India. It questions whether the US is repeating old mistakes by supporting another major economy that could eventually compete with it. The report claims these investments benefit global corporations and Indian industries, while causing job losses in the US.
India Responds with Confidence
India sees these concerns as misunderstandings. Indian leaders believe their actions are part of a smart and independent foreign policy. They argue that every country works to protect its own interests. India says attracting global money is a sign of strength, not manipulation. With strong economic growth and a talented workforce, India believes it is a smart choice for investment.
India argues that global growth is not a competition. Indian officials believe a growing India benefits the world, including the US. As India builds its economy, it also creates new markets for American companies and increases global trade. India does not see its rise as a threat but as an opportunity for stronger global partnerships.
Outsourcing Debate Continues
The US report worries about jobs moving to India, but India points out that its services help American businesses become more competitive. The Indian tech and service sectors have supported many American companies for years. Now, India is also focusing on high-tech manufacturing and research, not just outsourcing.
Despite criticism from some US media, India continues to value its relationship with the United States. The two countries work together in defense, technology, climate change, and more. Both share democratic values and common goals. The deepening relationship goes far beyond economic concerns.
Japan Welcomes India’s Rise
Japan sees India’s rise as positive. The two countries have strong ties, with Japan investing heavily in Indian infrastructure and technology. India and Japan work closely on regional issues and share long-term economic goals.
Germany Watches Closely
Germany has not issued a strong reaction, but experts there recognize India’s rise as a key moment in the global economy. German analysts mostly view India’s growth as an opportunity, not a threat, and expect deeper economic ties in the future.
India’s achievement in becoming the world’s fourth-largest economy is a proud moment. But not all global responses are the same. Some celebrate, while others worry. In the United States, especially among conservative voices, concern exists over how this growth might impact American workers and investments. For India, this shows the need to clearly explain its goals and continue working with international partners in a transparent and cooperative way.
As India climbs higher in the global rankings, it must navigate both praise and skepticism. How it manages these global perceptions will shape its future role on the world stage.
